This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more about our affiliate policy.
A black trench coat doesn’t care which aesthetic you woke up in. Same coat over a pleated skirt, a velvet dress, a flannel, or a fleece, and every time it reads like it was there first.
Secondhand is where the good ones live, because a real trench was built to outlast its first owner by a few decades. Hunt one good one instead of three mediocre jackets.
Here are 7 ways to wear a black trench, from academia to grunge, each with how to style it and which coat to grab. The men’s rack trick is in the last one, and it’s how you get the long, oversized silhouette for the least money.
Academia: black gabardine trench, ivory oxford shirt, forest green pleated skirt
The uniform version, and the easiest to get right. A black gabardine trench, belted, over an ivory oxford button-down, a forest green pleated midi skirt, black tights, and black oxfords. A brown leather satchel finishes it.
Buckle the belt and let the collar stand. That’s the entire difference between this and the grunge version at the bottom of the post.
This is the look where the name on the coat earns its keep, so here’s where to start.
- Go for the icon. A black Burberry runs $150 to $400, and the older ones feel the most substantial and hang the best.
- Grab the classic. London Fog is the sweet spot at $35 to $70. The older, heavier ones drape like the real thing, and the lighter mall versions are still honest coats.
- Check the quiet ones. Aquascutum, Brooks Brothers, and older Banana Republic all made proper gabardine trenches for well under Burberry money.
I broke down how to thrift dark academia outfits piece by piece.
Shop the look
Old Money: black trench worn open, camel cashmere turtleneck, charcoal flannel trousers
The mistake with old money is buttoning the coat. Leave it open, tie the belt at the back, and let a camel cashmere turtleneck and charcoal flannel wide leg trousers carry the colour. Black loafers, a cream pearl strand, done.
Camel and charcoal warm the black up until it reads as inherited, and it slots straight into the rest of the old money on a thrift store budget wardrobe.
Worn open, the coat is on show the whole time, so the way it hangs is everything.
Look for one that falls straight and clean past the knee and swings a little when you walk. A coat that hangs well open looks expensive before anyone clocks the cashmere. Pick the coat that drapes, and the rest of the outfit looks inherited too.
Fit lives in the shoulders. A soft, sloped shoulder lets you size down and still move, while a sharp, structured shoulder needs to land right on yours, so try that kind on over the turtleneck before you commit.
Shop the look
Heritage: black trench, cream waffle henley, dark raw denim
A real trench costs about what a decent flannel does secondhand, so let the coat do the talking. A black trench with the sleeves pushed up, a cream waffle knit henley, dark indigo raw denim in a straight leg, a brown leather belt, a charcoal scarf, and brown derbies. Collar popped, belt hanging loose through the loops.
Heritage wants the full military version of the coat, with all the old trench details still on it. That’s the one that hangs straighter and looks like it has a past.
- Let the belt hang. Leave it loose through the loops so it swings, which reads worn in instead of buttoned up.
- Push the sleeves. Shove them to the forearm so the henley cuff peeks out and the coat looks lived in.
- Go full detail. The more of the original trench trimmings it still has, the more heritage it reads. Pick that one over the stripped down trench-style jacket.
A heavy trench is a good trench. Hold it by the shoulders and the weight should pull the hem straight.
Shop the look
Whimsigoth: black trench, black crushed velvet midi dress, silver pendants
Velvet under a trench looks expensive from across the street. A black crushed velvet midi dress with bell sleeves pulled out past the coat cuffs, black tights, black Mary Janes, and layered silver celestial pendants over the dress with the coat open. Keep the belt out of it entirely.
The coat stays wide open here, so the inside and the shoulders get seen.
Every time you move, the inside of the coat flashes, so pick one that looks clean and cared for in there. Fixing a worn out inside costs more than the coat does.
Black cotton fades toward brown on the top of the shoulders and the collar where sun hits it. Compare the shoulder with the inside of the lapel; if they match, that coat lived in a closet. A faded shoulder is permanent; a dirty collar is not. $40 to $80 for one in good shape.
Shop the look
Y2K: black leather trench, white baby tee, dark rinse bootcut jeans
The one everyone wanted in 1999, and it’s suddenly cheap. A full length black leather trench, a plain white baby tee, dark rinse low rise bootcut jeans, narrow black tinted sunglasses, and black low sneakers. Coat open, jeans low; that proportion is the outfit.
The whole look rides on the coat being real leather, so this is the one place not to compromise.
- Skip the peely ones. Faux leather flakes at the collar and cuffs within a winter, and there’s no coming back from that.
- Trust your hands. Real leather looks a little uneven up close and warms up as you hold it. The fake stays cool and looks too perfect.
- Go soft for the sweep. Lambskin is light and drapes; cowhide is heavy and stiff. For the long Y2K swing, lambskin.
Wilsons Leather made thousands of these in the late 90s, and $60 to $150 buys a real one in black. Skip the $25 pleather version no matter how good it looks.
Shop the look
Gorpcore: black trench, olive deep pile fleece, black nylon track pants
This is the one outfit where the poly blend wins. A black trench from an outdoor label is lighter, dries faster, and sheds a real rain. Eddie Bauer, L.L.Bean, and Lands’ End all made trench-cut rain coats built for actual weather, and they run $25 to $50.
That lighter trench goes over an olive deep pile fleece pullover, black track pants, grey trail runners, and a black sling bag worn across the chest over the coat. Coat open, belt removed.
One sharp, tailored shape over three soft technical ones is why it works. Pull the fleece collar up inside the trench collar.
Shop the look
Grunge: black Wool trench, Ditzy Floral Maxi Dress, Doc Martens
The mistake is buying a trench that fits. An oversized black trench to mid calf over a red and black plaid flannel worn open with a ditzy floral maxi dress, and Dr. Martens. Sleeves shoved up, belt hanging from the loops, collar flat.
It’s the academia coat with every rule from that section switched off. More in how to thrift grunge style like it’s still 1994.
Here’s the trick: head to the men’s rack. A men’s trench already runs long and roomy, so you get the oversized, mid calf shape without paying extra for it.
Shop the look
One coat, seven settings
Seven outfits and the coat never changed.
Pick the length first. Knee or mid calf is one decision, and it rules out half of what’s out there. Then work through the rest of the outfit ideas with the coat already on.
It has been doing this since 1917.
